What Is The Difference Between an REO and a Short Sale?

Trying to buy a house but need to have it cheap to turn it better yourself? Or you just don’t have the funds as of now, which is why you came across REO and short sale homes? You are thinking yes, as long as the price is right and you are indeed right but there is a catch.


Homes like REO and short sales are below market price and the reason for that is they have issues to start with. Which will be a challenge for you later on.

 

What Is an REO?

REO stands for Real Estate Owned. It’s a home that has gone through the foreclosure process and is now owned by the bank or mortgage lender. No one bought the home at auction, so the bank took it back and is now trying to sell it.

Even though the bank is the seller, the home is often listed on the MLS, just like any other property. These homes are usually sold as-is, meaning the bank won’t fix anything before you buy it.

Why Do REOs Happen?

  • The homeowner missed too many mortgage payments.
     
  • The home was foreclosed on.
     
  • It didn’t sell at auction.
     
  • The bank now owns it and wants to get it off their books.
     

What to Expect with REOs:

  • You’ll work with a real estate agent to make an offer.
     
  • The bank usually doesn’t negotiate much on price or repairs.
     
  • You can still do inspections and get a loan.
     

A Real-Life Example:

Let’s say a family couldn’t make their mortgage payments anymore. The bank foreclosed on the home, but no one bought it at the courthouse auction. Now the bank owns it and lists it for sale through an agent.

 

What Is a Short Sale?

A short sale happens when a homeowner still owns the home, but they owe more money on the mortgage than the home is worth. They ask the bank for permission to sell the home for less than what they owe—that’s the “short” in short sale.

The bank has to approve the deal before it goes through.

Why Do Short Sales Happen?

  • The homeowner is struggling financially.
     
  • The housing market has dropped, and the home lost value.
     
  • The seller wants to avoid foreclosure.
     

What to Expect with Short Sales:

  • The homeowner still lives in the house.
     
  • You’ll make an offer, but then the bank must approve it.
     
  • The process can take a lot longer than a regular sale.
     

A Real-Life Example:

A homeowner owes $275,000 on a home that’s now worth only $240,000. They list it for $240,000 and find a buyer. The deal only closes if the bank agrees to accept less than the full amount owed.

 

How REOs and Short Sales Are Different

While both involve distressed homes, the process, timeline, and ownership are very different.

Feature

REO (Bank-Owned)

Short Sale

Who owns it?

The bank

The homeowner (with lender's permission)

When does it happen?

After foreclosure

Before foreclosure

Who approves the sale?

The bank directly

The homeowner & the bank

Are repairs likely?

Usually sold “as-is”

May still be maintained

Timeline

Medium

Long and unpredictable

Bargain potential

Often good

Also good, but depends on lender

 

Pros and Cons of REOs

Pros:

  • Priced below market value
     
  • Less emotional sellers (banks are more business-like)
     
  • No need for cash (traditional mortgages are allowed)
     

Cons:

  • Often need repairs
     
  • May have been vacant for a long time
     
  • “As-is” condition—no room for asking for fixes
     
  • Banks may take longer to respond
     
 

Pros and Cons of Short Sales

Pros:

  • May be in better shape than an REO
     
  • Can still negotiate with the seller directly
     
  • Often priced below market
     

Cons:

  • Slow process (may take 2–6 months or more)
     
  • Bank may say “no” even after a good offer
     
  • Seller must still be cooperative
     
  • You need to be flexible with your move-in timeline
     
 

Things to Keep in Mind

If you're thinking about buying an REO or a short sale property, it's important to stay patient, get pre-approved for a mortgage, and work with a real estate agent who understands the process.

These types of properties are not your average home purchase. There’s paperwork, delays, and extra steps. But if you have the time and guidance, they can also be great opportunities to buy below market value.

 

Ready to Buy Smart?

At RE/MAX Lakes Realty, we help buyers just like you every day—whether you’re looking at short sales, REOs, or just need guidance on the best deal in the area. Our team is experienced, responsive, and ready to help you navigate the process.

Let’s have a conversation. Whether you’re just curious or ready to buy, we’re here to make it simple.

Get In Touch

Community Updates

Silver Lake

Silver Lake in Lake Park

Silver Lake in Lake Park is a 1,000 acre lake with an average depth of about 6.5ft and a maximum depth of about 10ft. Silver Lake offers some of the best walleye fishing in the IGL's, especially in the spring and fall. The shoreline been developed with some beautiful homes, especially in South Shore Estates and West Bay Estates. Silver Lake is a wonderful spot so escape the hustle and bustle of other area lakes. It is a great lake to learn various water sports, as you won't encounter near the boat traffic. Do yourself a favor, and check out all that Silver Lake has to offer.

Real Estate and MLS Homes For Sale in Lake Park

Emerald Hills

Emerald Hills in Arnolds Park

Emerald Hills Golf Course is one of the premier golf courses in the Iowa Great Lakes. Golfers throughout Okoboji will tell you that compared to the rest of the golf courses around, Emerald Hills is probably the most challenging. When I grew up as a kid, we lived just a half block from the back side of the course. We would sneak on with a couple short little clubs and balls we found walking the course and sometimes spent more time being chased by the sprinklers than trying to hit golf balls. Emerald Hills was owned by Gordy and Bette Benit many years ago and they can be credited with growing this course into the masterpiece it has become. Later purchased by Randy Rohlfsen and a few others, Emerald has flourished as one of the best courses around. If memory serves me right, Randy has been there since the early 1990's and has always had a strong conviction to help young golfers. He has taught and coached numerous high school teams, and they also put on a 5 day junior camp every year which has been a tremendous hit. I grew up on this course and can honestly say, you better be hitting the ball straight!

Real Estate and MLS Homes For Sale in Arnolds Park

Arnold's Bark-ery

Arnold's Bark-ery in Arnolds Park

This new business to the lakes area is sure to be a hit! Arnold's Bark-ery makes healthy, fresh made snacks for all of the lucky dogs in the surrounding Okoboji area. They also provide natural, and holistic pet foods in their shop. A fun place to bring your dog to shop, as well as a place to get them groomed. What a fun addition to the area!

Real Estate and MLS Homes For Sale in Arnolds Park

Subscribe To Our Newsletter